"Christmas - the time to fix the computers of your loved ones" « Lord Wyrm

Bester "Top"-Luftkühler: Thermalright AXP-140

Joe_the_tulip 26.02.2009 - 14:32 3656 5
Posts

Joe_the_tulip

Editor
banned by FireGuy
Avatar
Registered: Mar 2003
Location: Wien
Posts: 16462
click to enlarge
Review @ X-bit labs
Zitat
As I have already mentioned above, the cooler boasts the highest quality of assembly. Unfortunately, we can’t say the same about the base – an Achilles heel of most Thermalright coolers.

...it covers the entire area around the CPU socket and hangs 15mm off the edge of the mainboard PCB when positioned this way. Note that it will be extremely inconvenient to plug in the 8-pin power connector, which is usually located in the upper left corner of the PCB.

... its efficiency dropped by 8-10°C under maximum CPU load compared with the installation when the heatpipe ends were facing up. ... It will make sense to remember that the cooler base is very uneven and the central contact spot is a little off. It looks like the contact was best for the highest heat transfer efficiency when we installed the cooler with its heatpipes facing up.

This allows us to conclude that Thermalright AXP-140 working in quiet fan mode will do perfectly fine with any existing processors.

Let’s start with the drawbacks. In my opinion, there are three of them and they can be lined up as follows in order of significance: support of LGA775 platform only, high price, limited compatibility.

Other than that, Thermalright AXP-140 with a 140 x 140 x 25mm fan is the most efficient “top” cooler today. It is not just efficient for CPU cooling, it also works well for the cooling of the area and components around the processor socket, which as a rule improves the overclocking results and system stability.

Viper780

Er ist tot, Jim!
Avatar
Registered: Mar 2001
Location: Wien
Posts: 50173
sehr nett, der XP-120 war ja nach wie vor der bete Topdown Kühler den es gab, leider am Markt fast nicht zu finden :(

XXL

insomnia
Avatar
Registered: Feb 2001
Location: /dev/null
Posts: 15703
Zitat von Viper780
sehr nett, der XP-120 war ja nach wie vor der bete Topdown Kühler den es gab, leider am Markt fast nicht zu finden :(

ich hab einen zu hause, war aber damals net schwer zu kriegen?

muss aber sagen meinen ifx geb ich so schnell nicht mehr her :D

Smut

Moderator
takeover & ether
Avatar
Registered: Feb 2003
Location: VIE
Posts: 16865
Zitat von Viper780
sehr nett, der XP-120 war ja nach wie vor der bete Topdown Kühler den es gab, leider am Markt fast nicht zu finden :(
besser als der SI-128 SE?

Viper780

Er ist tot, Jim!
Avatar
Registered: Mar 2001
Location: Wien
Posts: 50173
Zitat von Smut
besser als der SI-128 SE?

angeblich ja (laut spcr), den SI hatte ich nie.

@XXL damals nicht, jetzt aber schon, da fast nu rmehr billige Top Blow oder sehr viele Tower verbaut werden - Tower bekommst aber selten in Desktop cases, einen IFX 14 (wie ich ihn auch hab) bekommst nur in große Case, in meinen Threehundred geht der Backplane Kühler zB nimma rein und auch vorne is knapp

XXL

insomnia
Avatar
Registered: Feb 2001
Location: /dev/null
Posts: 15703
ich hab ihn 1 monat gekauft nachdem er heraussen war :D

stimmt, für kleine cases ist er nichts, wobei der xp-120 auch net grad so klein war ;)
Kontakt | Unser Forum | Über overclockers.at | Impressum | Datenschutz